Exploring how innovation, design & technology can reduce poverty at the Base of the Pyramid

Showing posts with label Singularity University. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Singularity University. Show all posts

Thursday, May 13, 2010

Two World Views in Design: Stanford D-School vs. Singularity University


Why are 90% of the world's products and services designed for 10% of the world's population? This is the question driving the approach of Stanford's course at the D-School called Alternative Design for Extreme Affordability. The course is a response to a fatigue by designers and engineers who grew tired of making products that only served a tiny fraction of the world's population. The vision of the school is to tackle the world's most hairy problems.

The founding architects at Singularity University are not asking quite the same question though they are interested in better serving that 90% of the population by using accelerating technology to impact a billion plus people in 10 years. Their vision is informed by the recognition that the pattern and pace of innovation has essentially remained at a consistent rate. But there is a point in which the technological innovation hits an exponential growth rate in its ability to be "improved." With modern technology we have hit that exponential growth rate and because of computers we are now reaching new frontiers in bio tech, nanotechnology, artificial intelligence, medicine and neuroscience at rates most of us never in imagined would occur in our life time.

But in my opinion the two approaches are light years apart. Though the two institutions are theoretically attempting to address this 90% of the population that remains critically under served by technological advances, affordability still remains an enormous barrier to access.

This is fodder for a much deeper discussion and debate but for the purposes of this blog, let's compare the utility, affordability and availability of a $10 treadle pump for someone living on $2 per day with a "printer" that can construct a house in one day for $3,000.

Let me close by provoking some debate with a few questions to consider. Embedded in these two approaches is an implicit notion of affordability and a view of the end user. The treadle pump has been designed in the field side by side with end user which has resulted in a more empathetically designed product. But the absence of the end user in mind when considering a product designed using accelerating technology leaves one to ask who are these products really designed for and which class of people will these products serve in the end? With that in mind, how can one distribute products that were designed to affect 1 billion + people if they aren't affordable. Or will the technology be imposed on a population without considering the repercussions?

In the end, it comes down to an issue of class. And cost determines which class has access to a innovative product or service. So, are accelerating technologies really a solution for some of the world's most intractable problems that affect a billion plus people if the price point remains out of reach for those living on dollars a day?

Wednesday, May 12, 2010

How to Prototype Faster in Development


Singularity University Executive Director Saleem Ishmail told us that every year their curriculum must be updated to keep pace with technologies at the frontiers of innovation. This made me ask myself how we at the Bank have been able to keep up with cutting edge approaches and technologies. We are often guilty for taking cookie cutter approach, for which the Bank is imfamous. More of us should be saying that this is no longer really acceptable, particularly given that every innovation has its own specific aspects that inform its design to fit it's cultural context. Not having this specificity often results in expensive failure that a country is ultimately responsible for and must pay back.

IDEO talked about prototyping to keep pace with innovations which automatically made me ask, how does the WB prototype? The simple answer is that it doesn't really. Yes, it does launch pilots but this is not an explicit strategy that ensures the approaches we are taking are truly innovation.

We at WBI are continually reflecting on our role and contribution to the mission of the WBG. So how can we at the Bank do development faster, better, smarter? IDEO approaches this problem by prototyping ideas to quickly test innovation.



I met with a Berkeley enineering professor who was working on a co-designed housing project with a Native American tribe in CA. They worked with the tribe on a housing project to design a single family dwelling that would ge them out of the government issued trailers where they lived. The tribe approached Native American Berekley students and collaboratively designed multiple iterations of a house that would be culturally relevant and would support their lifestyle and beliefs. Without these prototypes that were created and refined, this community may have ended up in another housing development project that was no more useful or appropriate than the trailers they were trying to escape.

In development we have seen many visions and designs created in the West plopped down in a community of a developing country only to be abandoned, destroyed or left vacant. With this in mind, grounded in the knowledge of the inumerable expensive white elephants the Bank has funded, a list of critical questions come to mind:

  • How can we ensure that a mindset, or practice of prototyping is an implicit part of project design at the Bank?
  • How can interdisciplinary teams help foster an iterative process without highjacking the process when collaborating with a country/community? More about IDEO's key components of productive brainstorming and collaboration in the next post.
  • What kind of cultural changes within the Bank will be required to foster more open communication and innovation?
  • How can risk be reconceptualized to inspire and support innovation within Bank operations that are loans that a developing country is obliged to pay back?

More later on our trip...! What are some of the questions that keep you up at night????

Tuesday, May 11, 2010

Singularity University

We're now in a meeting room at Singularity University.

We're sitting with Salim Ismail, Eric Dahlstrom, Susan Fonseca and a team-mate connected from home who literally rolled-in on a robot with a screen on top that displays his face!

See this TED video for an overview of some of their thinking, approaches and projects: TED Talk: Ray Kurzweil announces Singularity University

More to come...